2006-          The Very Reverend Catherine M. Thompson
2004-2006 The Reverend Elizabeth R. Ratcliff (interim)
1998-2004 The Reverend Richard M. Flynn
1982-1998 The Reverend Richard Taylor
1981-1982 The Reverend Paul Bigger (interim)
1974-1980 The Reverend John Harvey Klein
1966-1973 The Reverend Joel C. Treadwell
1961-1965 The Reverend Julian W. Jones
1952-1960 The Reverend Leslie E. Wilson
1950-1952 The Reverend David J. Coughlin
1946-1950 The Reverend Heber Williamson Weller
1941-1946 The Reverend Iveson B. Noland
1939-1940 The Reverend John Morgan
1937-1938 The Reverend J. E. Bauknight
1933-1936 The Reverend Anson Phelps Stokes, Jr.
1928-1933 The Reverend Richard Bolton
1925-1928 The Reverend Horace A. Holdrich
1922-1924 The Reverend E. J. Batty
1916-1918 The Reverend J. Orson Miller
1915-1916 The Reverend Sidney Dixon
1911-1914 The Reverend Sidney L. Vail
1907-1910 The Reverend John Gray
1898-1906 The Reverend Charles Thorpe
1897-1898 The Reverend A. R. Carson
1895-1895 The Reverend J. W. Gresham
1894-1894 The Reverend A. R. Price
1893-1894 The Reverend K. S. Guthrie
1891-1893 The Reverend M. Harrison
1887-1890 The Reverend W. Taylor Douglas
1886-1887 The Reverend R. H. Prosser
1885-1885 The Reverend M. T. Turner
1878-1883 The Reverend Charles A. Cameron
1872-1874 The Reverend J. Sandels
1870-1871 The Reverend Charles Ritter
1865-1865 The Reverend David Kerr
1861-1862 The Reverend William Binet
1853-1861 The Reverend Thomas Scott Bacon